Breathe Easy in Fort Collins: Simple, Personalized Renters Insurance from Independent Experts Since 1992
As independent brokers, we break down renters insurance to find the best fit for your needs—protecting your belongings, your peace of mind, and your Fort Collins lifestyle.
Finding the right car insurance shouldn't be complicated or expensive. We simplify the process and put YOU first.
Compare Top Carriers
Get unbiased access to quotes from multiple leading insurance companies, not just one.
Save Money
Our brokers work to find you the most competitive rates & discounts available.
Expert Local Advice
Get personalized guidance from licensed brokers who understand your specific insurance needs.
Renters Insurance Tailored to Your Fort Collins Lifestyle
Whether you’re settling into your first Fort Collins apartment, enjoying brewery nights in Old Town, or exploring local bike trails, our team designs clear, affordable renters insurance that protects what matters—without confusion or pressure. Discover the difference with local advisors who truly care.
Consult with a Local Expert
Book a call or drop by our Automation Way office to discuss your rental situation, questions, and goals. Our patient team gets to know you—no jargon, no judgment, just real help.
Compare Multiple Carrier Options
We’ll walk you through customized coverage choices. You’ll see side-by-side rates and protection comparisons from trusted insurers that specialize in renters in Fort Collins.
Secure Your Protection with Ongoing Support
Sign up quickly—most plans cost less than your monthly coffee habit. And whenever you need help (claims, updates, advice), you get real local support, not a call center.
Trusted by people
Just like you
Anytime I have a question or need anything I get a response immediately! They are great!!
The perfect mix of home town atmosphere and big city professionalism. I cannot recommend these guys enough, been using them for years and they always work extra hard to find me the best deal on insurance. If you're on the fence about using them, please go for it!!
Partnering with Leading Insurance Carriers:
Ready to See Your Savings?
The Hidden Costs of Not Understanding Renters Insurance
At Fort Collins Insurance Brokers, we take a different approach. As independent brokers, we patiently listen, demystify your options, and tailor affordable, right-fit policies that address your unique Fort Collins lifestyle, local risks, and moments of uncertainty.
Personalized Coverage Assessment
We start by learning about your Fort Collins rental, valuables, and priorities. Our step-by-step guidance uncovers coverage gaps and clarifies risks (like Colorado storms, bike theft, and unexpected costs) so you avoid costly mistakes.
Multi-Carrier Comparison
As independent brokers, we compare policies from leading insurers—showing you side-by-side costs, benefits, and local add-ons. Get honest advice and see your best options, never limited to just one company.
Why Fort Collins Renters Trust Fort Collins Insurance Brokers
For over three decades, we've been protecting what matters most with expertise, integrity, and personalized service that puts your needs first.
Independent Broker Advantage
Don’t get stuck with one-size-fits-all, single-company options. We compare multiple renters insurance carriers so you get choices, unbiased advice, and the local coverage fit you deserve—every time.
Personalized Client Education
Stuck on jargon? We break down everything—from coverage types to real-life examples. We’re patient, never pushy, ensuring you clearly understand what’s protected (and what’s not). No confusing fine print, just straight answers.
Local Expertise Since 1992
With 30+ years serving Fort Collins renters, we know the local risks—wild weather, bike theft, rental requirements. Our team lives here, shops here, and truly cares about your experience and protection.
Technology With a Personal Touch
Enjoy the ease of online quotes and digital tools, backed by real people who are a phone call or short drive away. Modern convenience, plus the warmth of genuine local support whenever you need it.
Dedicated Personal Advisor
No faceless support lines here. You always work with a local, dedicated advisor who takes time to answer every question and customizes coverage for your stage in life. Education is always part of our process.
Community-Focused Values
As Fort Collins locals, we invest in our city—supporting renters, local charities, and events. When you choose us, you back a neighbor who’s here for you for life, not just when you need a policy.
Great service experience. Melissa was very helpful and responsive.
Protect Your Fort Collins Life Today
Visit our Automation Way office or call us for your personalized renters insurance consultation. Experience the difference of working with local, independent experts who put your protection first, every time.
FAQs
Find answers to your most pressing questions and learn more about our services.
Some policies offer identity theft protection as an add-on. Check with your insurer for availability and details.
Standard policies usually exclude floods, earthquakes, pest infestations, and your roommate's belongings unless specifically added.
It's the amount you pay out of pocket on a claim before your insurance covers the remaining costs.
It covers certain types of water damage, like from burst pipes, but excludes flooding unless you have added flood coverage.
It typically covers personal property, liability, medical payments to others, and additional living expenses if your rental becomes uninhabitable.
Unlock Your Free Quote Now
What are you waiting for? Discover your options with a free, no-obligation quote today!