How do bundle discounts work with claims?

Bundle discounts typically remain active after a claim, though your overall premium may increase depending on your claims history in Colorado or Utah.

Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance partner, providing peace of mind with honest, expert guidance.

Complete Guide to Bundle Discounts and Claims

Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents

Understanding how claims affect bundle discounts is critical in Colorado and Utah, where local risk factors—like frequent hailstorms in Northern Colorado and wildfire threats in the Mountain West—directly impact insurance rates and claims frequency.

  • Local Weather Risks: Hail causes 42% of homeowner claims in Northern Colorado, with average roof repairs costing $17,000. Utah residents face increasing wildfire and winter-weather auto claims.
  • Market Consolidation: With 65% of the Colorado auto market owned by five carriers, local choices for bundles and claims experience can be limited.
  • Regional Deductibles: 70% of home policies now have percentage-based hail deductibles, affecting how much you pay out-of-pocket when a claim occurs—often higher in bundled scenarios for weather events.

What Most People Get Wrong

Many assume that filing a claim will automatically eliminate their bundle discount or that all claims have the same impact on their premium. In reality, the discount usually remains unless you drop one of the policies—what changes is your base premium after a claim, especially if you’ve had multiple losses.

Another common misunderstanding is not realizing that after a claim (such as hail or auto accident), your regional risk profile and claims history play a bigger role in determining next year's premium.

The Complete Picture

When you purchase a home and auto bundle, you secure a discount—typically 11–26% off combined premiums in Colorado and Utah. If you need to file a claim, the bundle discount itself generally continues as long as both policies remain active and paid. However, your base premium (the amount before discounts) may rise after a claim, especially in high-risk claim years for weather events or accidents.

Premium increases post-claim are common in the region, but bundling offers important stability—bundled clients in Colorado see 15% lower premium hikes after a loss compared to those with single policies, thanks to carrier loyalty incentives. Note: for weather claims, you may face higher or percentage-based deductibles and, in some cases, Actual Cash Value (ACV) restrictions on roofs, impacting net claim value. Bundling can give you access to single-deductible programs for simultaneous losses (like hail damaging home and auto at once), further improving your experience.

Always request clear documentation on how claims history affects base premiums and verify deductible structures on your bundled policies, especially for hail or wildfire risks in the region.

Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents

Question 1: What is the impact of a claim on my bundle discount and total cost?

Filing a claim typically does not remove your bundle discount, but can increase your base premium. Consider:

  • Retention matters: Bundled clients get better rates post-claim
  • Deductibles vary: Regional hail/wildfire claims may require larger out-of-pocket costs—verify your deductible type

Question 2: Does my bundle include claim-forgiveness or single-deductible features?

Some Colorado and Utah carriers offer claim-forgiveness or single-deductible perks for bundled customers, especially for events like hailstorms. Ask your agent if your bundle includes these benefits and under what scenarios they apply—it's a big difference if your home and car are damaged in one event.

Question 3: How do I proactively manage my risk to minimize premium increases after a claim?

Take preventive steps relevant to regional risks:

  • Install home roof upgrades, security, or fire mitigation systems
  • Attend a defensive driving course
  • Document property condition before hail season (especially in Northern Colorado)

This proactive approach can help keep premiums manageable and maximize your bundle’s long-term value.

Trusted by Your Neighbors

Local knowledge, industry-leading protection

4.9/5 Stars

Google Reviews from real customers

97% Retention Rate

Fort Collins families and businesses protected

Independent

We work for you, not insurance companies

Local

Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992

Real World Examples

Fort Collins Fender Bender—Staying Protected

Background: Lisa, a Fort Collins local, bundled her home and auto policies with her agent to save on her insurance costs.

Coverage: State Farm bundle with $250,000 dwelling coverage and $100,000/$300,000 auto liability.

Monthly Premium: $325/month ($3,900/year)

The Incident: Lisa accidentally backed into another vehicle at the Harmony Road Safeway, causing $3,200 in damages.

Total Claim Cost: $3,200 (auto body repair, no injuries)

Lisa's Cost: $500 deductible—her bundle kept the process streamlined, and next renewal reflected only a modest $11/month increase.

"I'm so glad everything stayed with one company—I didn't have to chase anyone down, and my bundle discount really stuck. Premium went up a little after the claim, but the discount saved me more than that at renewal."

Salt Lake City Hailstorm—Double Trouble, One Solution

Background: David and Rosa bundled their Salt Lake City home (Liberty Park area) and vehicles with Farmers Insurance.

Coverage: $400,000 replacement cost home coverage, $250,000 auto liability, and $1,000 comprehensive deductible across both policies.

Monthly Premium: $370/month ($4,440/year) after bundle discount

The Incident: A sudden May hailstorm damages their roof and both cars parked outside. Both home and auto claims are filed together.

Total Claim Cost: $15,800 (roof $13,000, cars $2,800 combined)

David & Rosa's Cost: $1,000 single-weather-event deductible (special bundle feature avoided paying $3,000+, and they received help with repairs and emergency tarping).

"Our agent explained we'd still get our bundle savings after the claim, and we only had to pay one deductible! That really took the sting out of a rough surprise."

Boulder Wildfire Worries—Comprehensive Support

Background: Ethan, a Boulder homeowner and Prius driver, used a USAA bundle for 7 years.

Coverage: $600,000 home replacement, $100,000/$300,000 auto, replacement cost roof, $1,000 home deductible.

Monthly Premium: $468/month ($5,616/year) after loyalty discount

The Incident: During a late-summer wildfire threat in 2024, Ethan evacuated on short notice. Embers damaged siding, and wind-blown debris broke his car window.

Total Claim Cost: $7,750 (home repairs $6,100, auto glass $1,650)

Ethan's Cost: $1,000 deductible; USAA handled both claims together, and premium increase was limited ($19/month new rate), but he kept his 9% bundle discount.

"Having everything under one roof was huge—the discount stuck, and my agent navigated both claims while Boulder was still on alert."

Avoid These Common Mistakes

Mistake #1: Assuming Claims Cancel Your Bundle Discount

What People Do: Some assume that any claim will eliminate their bundle discount and shop around unnecessarily after an incident.

Why It Seems Logical: It's easy to fear a penalty or lost discount after a claim, especially when hearing about premium hikes from friends or online forums.

The Real Cost: In Colorado and Utah, moving carriers post-claim often means losing loyalty rate protections, facing underwriting scrutiny, and paying higher standalone home/auto rates—potentially $400–$1,000 more per year.

Smart Alternative: Stay with your bundle after a claim, request clear documentation on any premium change, and verify you retain all eligible discounts. FoCoIns helps clarify your rights and the true cost-benefit after a loss.

Mistake #2: Ignoring Regional Deductible Types in Your Bundle

What People Do: Many bundle clients fail to check if their policy uses percentage-based deductibles for hail (CO) or wildfire (UT) claims.

Why It Seems Logical: Bundles are marketed for simplicity, so some believe all deductibles work the same for every claim event.

The Real Cost: A 1% hail deductible on a $400,000 home is a $4,000 out-of-pocket expense. Not budgeting for large deductibles can create hardship when extreme weather hits.

Smart Alternative: Use FoCoIns’ comparison tools to request bundles with fixed-dollar deductibles or clearly defined maximums for your region. Review coverage annually as providers update deductible structures.

Mistake #3: Overlooking How Claims History Impacts Base Premiums—Not Just Discounts

What People Do: Some focus only on the bundle discount and don't ask how a claim will affect their underlying premium, especially after multiple claims.

Why It Seems Logical: Discount messaging gets more attention than what causes premiums to rise after a loss.

The Real Cost: Multiple or severe claims can increase your base rate by 15–25% at renewal, even with the discount still in place—translating to $500+ per year in higher costs for most CO or UT families.

Smart Alternative: Work with a FoCoIns advisor to understand base premium trends in your ZIP code and use risk mitigation strategies to minimize future hikes while preserving your bundle status.

FAQs On The Same Topic

Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.