How does COBRA continuation coverage work?
COBRA lets you temporarily keep your employer health insurance after leaving a job, but you'll pay the full premium plus a small administrative fee. It's a lifeline for coverage continuity but can be costly—compare all options before enrolling.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance partner, providing peace of mind through expert guidance.
Complete Guide to COBRA Continuation Coverage
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
Health coverage disruptions can be financially devastating, especially with regional average family premiums in Colorado hitting $25,572 in 2024 and out-of-pocket costs rising. With employer-sponsored insurance less common in small businesses—just 27.6% offer benefits in 2023—and employees shouldering 31% of family premium costs in our region, knowing how to maintain coverage after job loss or a life change is critical.
- Sudden Loss of Coverage: With layoffs and job changes affecting both urban and rural communities like Fort Collins, Denver, or Salt Lake City, COBRA can provide crucial continuity.
- Regional Costs and Financial Impact: Full COBRA premiums mean paying not just your share, but also the employer's. In Colorado and Utah, this typically means $2,130–$2,400/month for family plans plus a 2% admin fee.
- Alternatives Available: State exchanges like Connect for Health Colorado or Healthcare.gov in Utah may offer lower premiums, especially with income-based subsidies.
What Most People Get Wrong
Many believe COBRA will be similarly priced to their prior contributions—in reality, costs often triple when you pay both the employer and employee share. Others wait too long and miss the strict 60-day enrollment window, losing eligibility altogether. Not comparing Marketplace alternatives can cost families thousands yearly.
Some also assume all dependents will always qualify, but special rules sometimes affect domestic partners and stepchildren under regional plan definitions. Understanding these nuances is essential in Colorado and Utah.
The Complete Picture
COBRA (Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act) allows employees and covered dependents to temporarily continue their existing group health plan after losing job-based coverage due to qualifying events (job loss, hours reduction, divorce, etc.). Under federal law and reinforced by ACA mandates, most employers in Colorado and Utah with 20 or more employees must offer COBRA. You have 60 days from the date your coverage ends or from receiving your COBRA notice (whichever is later) to elect coverage—don't delay!
Coverage typically lasts up to 18 months, with extensions in certain cases. You'll pay the entire premium (average $711/mo. for single, $2,130–$2,400/mo. for family, plus a 2% admin fee), and deductible resets may apply. Make sure to compare COBRA to options through state or federal exchanges—many Coloradans and Utahns now qualify for subsidies that significantly lower those premiums and out-of-pocket costs. COBRA is often best if you're mid-treatment or want to avoid changing networks, but it may not be the most cost-effective long-term solution in our region's insurance landscape.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: What are my total monthly costs and alternatives?
Before choosing COBRA, ask:
- What is the full COBRA premium (employer + employee share + 2% fee)?
- How do costs compare to Marketplace plans (Connect for Health Colorado, Healthcare.gov Utah)?
- Do I qualify for ACA subsidies or Medicaid based on current income?
Question 2: Does COBRA make sense for my medical situation?
If you're mid-treatment, expecting a child, or value uninterrupted access to existing doctors/hospitals, COBRA can be worth the higher price. Otherwise, Marketplace plans may offer better value, especially for those in good health or open to changing providers. Example: If you're continuing specialist care at UCHealth in Fort Collins or Intermountain in Salt Lake City, COBRA might prevent disruption.
Question 3: Have I considered the timing and deadlines?
The enrollment window is strict—once 60 days pass, COBRA is off the table. Plan your next steps fast. If you anticipate a new job soon with benefits—could short-term insurance bridge the gap? If not, compare all options and enroll promptly. Geographic access matters, too: rural residents may have different plan networks and availability.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
COBRA Coverage After a Layoff in Fort Collins
Background: After being laid off from his marketing job in Old Town Fort Collins, Alex faced a tough decision: how to keep health insurance for his family of four.
Coverage: His employer plan covered major medical, dental, and vision. The monthly premium was previously $650 (employee share), with the total cost at $2,150.
Monthly Premium: $2,193/month ($26,316/year)
The Incident: Shortly after the layoff, Alex's spouse needed knee surgery. COBRA let them keep their surgeons and hospital with no lapse in coverage while job searching.
Total Claim Cost: $14,300 (surgery, PT, follow-up visits)
Alex's Cost: $1,200 (deductible and coinsurance; premium covered rest)
"Paying COBRA felt overwhelming at first, but knowing my family wouldn’t lose coverage or have to change doctors mid-crisis was a huge relief."
Navigating a Divorce in Denver with COBRA
Background: Jennifer, a Denver resident, lost coverage when her divorce was finalized. She had 60 days to decide how to keep her health insurance.
Coverage: Her employer-sponsored PPO plan offered broad provider access. Full COBRA cost: $813/month for individual coverage.
Monthly Premium: $813/month ($9,756/year)
The Incident: Two months post-divorce, Jennifer needed a minor outpatient procedure. COBRA continuity avoided prior authorization delays and network changes.
Total Claim Cost: $2,050 (procedure & follow-up)
Jennifer's Cost: $400 (deductible and coinsurance; premium covered remainder)
"COBRA was expensive, but for my situation it was worth it. Avoiding the hassle of switching networks in the middle of everything else gave me peace of mind."
Job Transition in Salt Lake City: A Strategic COBRA Use
Background: Brian, from Salt Lake City, was moving between jobs with a two-month gap in benefits. He weighed COBRA versus a Marketplace plan.
Coverage: His prior employer plan covered him, his spouse, and one child. COBRA offered identical coverage for $1,978/month.
Monthly Premium: $1,978/month ($23,736/year)
The Incident: During the gap, Brian’s child needed ongoing allergy treatment.
Total Claim Cost: $1,900 (specialist visits, prescriptions)
Brian's Cost: $350 (copays and coinsurance)
"I calculated that paying for two months of COBRA kept our care consistent until my new job’s insurance started. It wasn’t cheap, but for such a short period, it was manageable."
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Missing the 60-Day COBRA Enrollment Window
What People Do: Many wait until the last minute to decide, believing they have more time or may find a new job immediately, and miss the strict federal deadline.
Why It Seems Logical: It's tempting to delay while exploring other options or hoping circumstances change.
The Real Cost: Once 60 days pass, you lose COBRA rights entirely. In Colorado and Utah, this means losing access to company plans that might protect you from a $10,000+ hospital bill if an emergency happens after your old coverage expires.
Smart Alternative: As soon as you get your COBRA notice, decide promptly—compare costs, explore Marketplace options, and act quickly before the window closes. FoCoIns advisors can walk you through decisions so you don't miss out due to paperwork delays or confusion.
Mistake #2: Overlooking Marketplace or Subsidized Alternatives
What People Do: People enroll in COBRA automatically, assuming it’s their only or best option, without exploring state exchange plans (Connect for Health Colorado or Healthcare.gov Utah).
Why It Seems Logical: Keeping the same coverage feels simpler and more familiar during a stressful life change.
The Real Cost: Skipping the Marketplace could mean missing out on premium tax credits or subsidies—sometimes saving $500+ per month. Especially in high-cost markets like Denver or Park City, this can add up to $6,000 or more annually.
Smart Alternative: Always compare COBRA to the state or federal health exchange plans. FoCoIns can provide a side-by-side analysis, ensuring you don’t pay more than necessary for equivalent or even better coverage in Colorado and Utah.
Mistake #3: Assuming All Dependents Are Automatically Covered
What People Do: People assume their entire family, including stepchildren or domestic partners, are COBRA-eligible because they were on the prior plan.
Why It Seems Logical: It's reasonable to expect continuation for everyone already insured.
The Real Cost: Some Colorado and Utah employer plans restrict COBRA eligibility for non-legal dependents or domestic partners, especially in smaller or self-insured businesses. Your child or partner could lose coverage unexpectedly, risking uncovered claims or expensive out-of-pocket bills ranging from $5,000–$25,000 for major events.
Smart Alternative: Double-check eligibility for all dependents before electing COBRA, and consider supplemental Marketplace options if any aren’t covered. FoCoIns can clarify your family's exact situation and help secure alternatives quickly if needed.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.