What is short-term disability insurance?

Short-term disability insurance provides partial income replacement if you can't work due to a covered illness or injury, typically for 3-6 months. It's essential protection for financial stability during recovery.

Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance advisor, providing local expertise and protection for working families.

Complete Guide to Short-Term Disability Insurance

Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents

Short-term disability insurance is a crucial, yet often misunderstood, part of employee benefits, especially in regions like Colorado and Utah where a large percentage of workers rely on their salaries to cover daily expenses. Due to recent trends of rising healthcare costs and a shift towards high-deductible health plans (HDHPs) in both states, understanding income protection options is more important than ever.

  • Local cost-sharing is higher than the national average: Colorado employees pay about 31% of family premiums—higher than the 28% US average. Short-term disability can be a vital safety net when regular paychecks are interrupted.
  • Medical bankruptcies and lost wages are real risks: Uninsured or underinsured workers in our region face a 53% higher risk of medical bankruptcy, underlining the importance of wage protection.
  • Employer coverage varies widely, especially for small businesses: Only about 27% of Colorado small firms offer employee benefits, making voluntary or self-purchased disability coverage a key option for many workers.

What Most People Get Wrong

Many Colorado and Utah residents assume short-term disability is automatically included in all benefits packages. In reality, small employers often don't offer it—and even for those who do, coverage details can vary significantly.

Another common misconception: believing workplace injuries are always covered by workers' comp, when most short-term disability claims actually result from illness, pregnancy, or surgeries not related to work accidents.

The Complete Picture

Short-term disability insurance is an insurance policy that pays a percentage of your regular income—often 50% to 70%—if you are unable to work due to a covered medical condition. Coverage typically begins after a short waiting period (7 to 14 days) and lasts from 3 to 6 months, depending on your policy. This protection helps families meet essential expenses like rent, groceries, and utilities when illness, injury, or medical recovery interrupts income.

For Colorado and Utah employees in fields like tech, healthcare, education, and agriculture, real-life risks (from sports injuries to seasonal illnesses) make short-term disability an essential consideration. With the average annual premium inflation for employee benefits in our region at 7%, evaluating the right policy for your needs—and employer contribution—can protect both your wallet and your wellbeing.

Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents

Question 1: What is my actual risk of income loss if I can't work for several weeks or months?

Assess your personal and family finances:

  • Can you cover rent, mortgage, and essential bills if you lose two to six months of pay?
  • Does your employer offer short-term disability, and if so, what percentage of your paycheck will it cover (usually 50-70%)?

Question 2: What are the specific terms of coverage available to me?

Read your benefit summary carefully or ask your HR/benefits contact:

  • Look for waiting periods (often 7-14 days before benefits start), maximum benefit durations, and exclusions (pre-existing conditions, elective surgery, etc.).
  • If considering an individual policy (especially if self-employed or your employer doesn't offer coverage), compare costs, benefits, and carrier reputation—FoCoIns can help you benchmark local options.

Question 3: How do local and family factors affect my decision?

Colorado and Utah have higher rates of family coverage cost-sharing and a larger proportion of small businesses that might not offer disability. Consider if you have high fixed expenses or limited emergency savings, especially in regions where seasonal work or self-employment is common (e.g., agriculture near Greeley, tech startups in Boulder or Salt Lake City).

Trusted by Your Neighbors

Local knowledge, industry-leading protection

4.9/5 Stars

Google Reviews from real customers

97% Retention Rate

Fort Collins families and businesses protected

Independent

We work for you, not insurance companies

Local

Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992

Real World Examples

Jane's Recovery in Fort Collins

Background: Jane is a marketing manager at a Fort Collins tech company. An avid runner, she suffered a severe leg injury during the Horsetooth Half Marathon and needed surgery, forcing her out of work for eight weeks.

Coverage: Her employer’s short-term disability benefit provided 60% of her $5,000/month salary after a two-week waiting period—$3,000/month in coverage.

Monthly Premium: $32/month ($384/year), fully covered by her employer as part of a competitive benefits package.

The Incident: After her surgery, Jane faced physical therapy and could not return to work for two months. Her benefits kicked in after the waiting period and allowed her to keep up with rent and medical co-pays while focusing on recovery and not financial stress.

Total Claim Cost: $6,000 (2 months of coverage)

Jane's Cost: $0 premium (employer-paid), only minor out-of-pocket for medical co-pays not covered by her health plan.

"Short-term disability gave me peace of mind when I needed it most. I never worried about my bills, so I could focus on healing and getting back to work."

Mike's Surgery Leave in Denver

Background: Mike works as a service technician for a regional HVAC company based near Denver’s I-25 corridor. In early spring, a non-work-related hernia sidelined him for six weeks.

Coverage: The company’s disability plan replaced 66% of his $3,600/month wages.

Monthly Premium: $19/month ($228/year), half paid by the employer, half by Mike through payroll deduction.

The Incident: Mike submitted paperwork the day after his doctor confirmed the need for surgery. After a 7-day waiting period, he received $2,376/month—enough to cover his family’s mortgage and groceries. Without the benefit, his family would have needed to dip into limited savings, as his wife works part-time with variable income.

Total Claim Cost: $3,564 (for 6 weeks of partial income replacement)

Mike's Cost: $114 for his share of annual premium, $250 in claim paperwork costs (doctor's documentation, not always covered by health insurance).

"If we hadn't had disability coverage, we would have gone through our entire emergency fund. This made a stressful health scare much more manageable."

Sophia's C-Section Recovery in Salt Lake City

Background: Sophia is an elementary school teacher in Salt Lake City. After medical advice led to a planned C-section, she learned her short-term disability plan would cover part of her missed income during maternity leave.

Coverage: School district plan paid 70% of her $4,100/month salary for up to 8 weeks for childbirth recovery.

Monthly Premium: $24/month ($288/year), payroll deducted.

The Incident: Sophia’s disability benefit began after a 7-day waiting period and provided $2,870/month—helping her keep up with student loan payments and rent in downtown Salt Lake during the eight-week leave not fully covered by sick days.

Total Claim Cost: $5,740 (8 weeks of benefits)

Sophia's Cost: $288 for her annual premium, $0 out-of-pocket for paperwork.

"This benefit took a huge weight off my shoulders after childbirth. It allowed me to recover and spend time with my newborn without financial anxiety."

Avoid These Common Mistakes

Mistake #1: Assuming Workers’ Compensation Covers All Disabilities

What People Do: Some employees in Colorado and Utah believe that workers’ comp will pay if they miss work due to any disability.

Why It Seems Logical: Both programs provide income replacement, leading to confusion.

The Real Cost: Workers' comp only covers job-related injuries—over 70% of disability claims are unrelated to work. Without separate short-term disability, an illness or accident off the job (like a skiing injury in Breckenridge) could mean zero income for weeks, risking $2,500–$5,000/month in lost wages.

Smart Alternative: Confirm your benefit details. If your employer doesn’t provide short-term disability, compare affordable private plans with help from a FoCoIns advisor. They can clarify what's covered and recommend tailored protection for your situation.

Mistake #2: Overlooking Waiting Periods and Benefit Amounts

What People Do: Many employees don’t review their policy’s waiting period or income-replacement percentage, assuming it will cover their full paycheck from day one of a disability.

Why It Seems Logical: It’s easy to expect benefits to start right away and make up all lost earnings.

The Real Cost: Most policies have a 7-14 day waiting period, and cover 50-70% of gross salary—not 100%. Missing this detail can lead to a $1,500-$2,500/month shortfall during recovery, especially with higher cost-sharing in Colorado.

Smart Alternative: Before an emergency, check your exact coverage, waiting period, and benefit maximum. Discuss strategies to fill any gaps—like building an emergency fund—with your FoCoIns advisor.

Mistake #3: Only Considering Premiums, Not the Value of Coverage

What People Do: Some workers (especially at smaller firms in Utah and Colorado) decline disability coverage to save a few dollars per paycheck, viewing it as "nice to have" rather than essential protection.

Why It Seems Logical: Disability usually feels unlikely, so minimizing upfront costs seems reasonable.

The Real Cost: Saving $20–$30/month in premiums could mean losing $3,000–$8,000 (or more) in income if an accident or illness strikes. Short-term disability helps avoid dipping into savings or falling behind on critical bills.

Smart Alternative: Consider your total risk, not just premium costs. A quick consultation with FoCoIns can help you weigh the benefits versus the small monthly investment—often fully or partially offset by employer contributions in larger CO/UT firms.

FAQs On The Same Topic

Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.