When should I get homeowners insurance when buying a house?
You should have homeowners insurance in place before closing—lenders require proof to finalize your mortgage. Arranging coverage early ensures you're protected from day one.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance advisor, providing clarity, confidence, and peace of mind.
Complete Guide to When to Get Homeowners Insurance
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
Timing your homeowners insurance is not just an administrative step—it's a financial and legal requirement in both Colorado and Utah, with significant consequences for your purchase and future protection. Regional hazards like wildfires, hail, and rising rebuilding costs make proper, timely coverage even more crucial.
- Mortgage Requirements: Lenders in CO and UT will not allow you to close without valid homeowners insurance. Proof of coverage is mandatory for mortgage approval.
- Immediate Protection from Local Risks: Colorado faces the second-highest rate of hail and wildfire claims in the U.S. (average premiums $3,320/year); policies must be active to cover these from the moment you get the keys.
- Unlocking Discounts: New builds in both states average 45% lower premiums than older homes; securing insurance early may lock in better rates and keep your closing on schedule.
What Most People Get Wrong
Many first-time buyers think they can secure insurance after closing. In reality, your lender will require proof of coverage often days before closing—waiting can cause stressful delays, last-minute scrambling, or even losing your rate lock or home. Another misconception is that shopping for the cheapest policy is all that matters; this often leaves gaps in coverage, especially in high-risk Colorado/Utah counties.
It's also common to underestimate how regional perils like wildfire and hail can impact insurability and deductibles. Some areas may require documentation of mitigation efforts and may have restricted coverage windows around natural disaster season, making last-minute insurance much riskier.
The Complete Picture
To avoid closing delays and ensure you’re protected from the second you take ownership, connect with an agent like FoCoIns as soon as your offer is accepted. Start by gathering details about your prospective home (square footage, roof age, safety features) and let your agent shop competitive carriers for you. In Colorado, the average annual premium is $3,320, but new homes can be as low as $1,800. In Utah, averages are lower but on the rise due to similar weather trends. Lenders may require a paid policy or binder several business days before closing—plan for this by getting an early quote and confirming your effective date matches your closing. Ask about discounts for security systems, updated roofs, and hail-resistant materials. Remember: your insurance not only protects your new investment from physical damage, but also satisfies legal and lender requirements unique to our region.
Regulatory Note: Colorado’s new HB23-1174 requires expanded replacement cost coverage, so getting a head start helps you understand your options and lock in the right policy for your home’s true rebuilding cost.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: Does my coverage meet my lender’s (and state law’s) requirements?
Ask your agent to review all lender stipulations, including minimum dwelling coverage, replacement cost requirements (especially under Colorado HB23-1174), and any required endorsements. Don’t overlook regional add-ons like wildfire mitigation or hail-resistant roof credits!
- Check for minimum coverage amounts set by your mortgage lender.
- Ensure policy meets state-mandated notice and cancellation periods.
Question 2: Am I protected from day one—against the risks that matter here?
Given CO’s wildfire and hail frequency, and UT’s fast-growing population and severe weather, confirm your policy starts the day you take ownership. Ask about gaps for flood, water backup, or ordinance and law coverage (to cover code upgrades if you must rebuild).
Question 3: Have I planned for premium payment and proof of insurance timing?
Lenders generally require a paid binder before closing—typically 3-7 days in advance. Build insurance selection into your homebuying checklist alongside inspection and appraisal deadlines. Failure to provide timely proof can jeopardize closing or cost you your dream home.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
Fort Collins Closing: Anna’s Homebuying Timeline
Background: Anna found her dream home near Harmony Road in Fort Collins and set a mid-June closing date. As a first-time buyer, she focused on securing her loan, almost forgetting about insurance until her lender requested proof 10 days before closing.
Coverage: $375,000 dwelling with $200,000 liability, $100,000 personal property, replacement cost endorsement
Monthly Premium: $225/month ($2,700/year)
The Incident: The week before closing, a major hailstorm hit Larimer County. Because Anna had already secured coverage with an effective date matching closing, her new roof was covered two months later after closing—even though the storm happened before she took possession.
Total Claim Cost: $16,400 (roof and siding replacement)
Anna’s Cost: $2,000 deductible – the rest paid by insurance.
“Thank goodness I locked in insurance early. My lender said our closing would have been delayed otherwise—and after the storm, I really understood the value of acting ahead!”
Salt Lake City Story: Dan’s Mortgage Hiccup
Background: Dan was excited to close on a renovated home in Sugar House, Salt Lake City, but waited until three days before closing to shop for insurance. His lender required a specific amount of dwelling coverage and proof of a paid premium before funding.
Coverage: $430,000 dwelling, $150,000 personal property, $300,000 liability
Monthly Premium: $190/month ($2,280/year)
The Incident: Because Dan delayed, his insurance documents weren’t ready in time and he nearly missed his rate lock. He scrambled, paid a rush underwriting fee, and got stuck with a basic policy missing water backup coverage, which cost him an extra $600 later to add.
Total Claim Cost: N/A (but future water backup claim could have been denied if not amended in time)
Dan’s Cost: $150 rush fee + $600 for coverage correction
“Lesson learned—I wish I’d started the insurance process sooner. The delay nearly cost me the house.”
Boulder’s Wildfire Window: Emily’s Proactive Approach
Background: Emily purchased a hillside home west of Broadway Ave. in Boulder—a high wildfire-risk zone. She knew some insurers restrict new policies immediately before or during wildfires, due to regional underwriting freezes.
Coverage: $750,000 dwelling, $300,000 liability, extended replacement cost, wildfire mitigation credits
Monthly Premium: $345/month ($4,140/year)
The Incident: Emily started her insurance application as soon as her offer was accepted—weeks before closing. Days later, a wildfire erupted in nearby foothills—her neighbors who hadn’t prearranged coverage got denied or delayed, while Emily’s in-force policy ensured smooth closing and immediate protection.
Total Claim Cost: No claim yet, but immediate coverage in place even if disaster struck.
Emily’s Cost: Standard premium and peace of mind
“FoCoIns flagged the wildfire underwriting freeze early. I’d have been uninsurable if I’d waited—getting coverage before closing truly saved my move.”
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Waiting Until the Last Minute to Secure a Policy
What People Do: Buyers often assume insurance is a quick formality and leave it to the final week before closing.
Why It Seems Logical: With so much paperwork and other buying steps, it’s easy to underestimate the processing time for insurance quotes, inspections, and underwriting.
The Real Cost: Last-minute applications can delay your closing, cost you a rate lock, or force you into an expensive, limited-coverage policy. In Colorado, some underwriters won’t bind new policies near wildfire events, so waiting could leave you uninsured and ineligible for your mortgage.
Smart Alternative: Engage a FoCoIns advisor as soon as your offer is accepted. We can help you shop coverage early, meet lender timelines, and avoid stress from underwriting bottlenecks—especially in high-risk or busy seasons.
Mistake #2: Using the Wrong Effective Date for Your Policy
What People Do: Some buyers accidentally set their policy to start before or after the actual closing date, not matching the real transfer of ownership.
Why It Seems Logical: Dates can change with closing delays, and some buyers try to save money by starting coverage a day or two late.
The Real Cost: If your coverage starts after closing, you’ll have a gap where your home may be uninsured—leaving you financially exposed to fire, theft, or weather events. Starting too early means you pay for coverage while the seller is still legally responsible.
Smart Alternative: Confirm with your agent and title company that coverage goes into effect exactly when you take possession. For most, this is the actual closing date. We coordinate these details so you’re covered the second you own your home—no gaps, no wasted premium.
Mistake #3: Focusing Only on Price, Not Coverage
What People Do: Buyers rush to choose the cheapest policy to satisfy the lender without considering what’s actually covered.
Why It Seems Logical: Buying a home is expensive, so lowering upfront costs is appealing—especially when insurance seems like just another box to check.
The Real Cost: Basic policies often miss essential protections (like water backup, replacement cost instead of actual cash value, or ordinance and law coverage). In Colorado, for example, 38% of wildfire claims are underinsured and 15-35% discounts are missed by not selecting hail-resistant options. A poorly chosen policy could mean $25,000+ uncovered losses during a claim.
Smart Alternative: Let FoCoIns help you review and explain all policy details—not just premium. We’ll ensure you have the right protection for your home, so you aren’t caught off guard when it matters most.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.