Protect Everything That Makes Your Rental a Home
Trusted by Renters Since 1992
Our independent advisors have decades of experience protecting what matters most to renters, with access to 26 top-rated insurance carriers.
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers, just like you
97% Retention
Customers stay with us year over year over year
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Renters Insurance: Your Financial Safety Net
Nobody expects to need insurance – until they do. See how renters insurance protects you when the unexpected happens.
The Costly Coffee Spill
Marcus accidentally knocked over his coffee onto his laptop while working from his rental. His renters policy covered the $1,200 replacement cost after his $250 deductible. Without coverage, he would have paid the full amount out-of-pocket and disrupted his work schedule for weeks.
His premium of $15/month saved him nearly $1,000 and kept his professional life on track.
The Neighbor's Bathroom Flood
When Emma's upstairs neighbor's bathtub overflowed, water damaged her ceiling, walls, and several pieces of furniture. Her renters policy covered temporary housing ($2,800) and replacement of her damaged belongings ($3,500). Her neighbor's insurance covered the structural repairs.
Without renters insurance, Emma would have been out $6,300 and potentially homeless during repairs.
The Liability Lawsuit
David's friend tripped on a loose rug in his apartment, resulting in a broken arm and medical bills. The friend's health insurance company sought $45,000 from David as the responsible party. David's renters liability coverage fully protected him from this claim, covering legal fees and the settlement.
For less than $18/month, his policy prevented a devastating financial setback that could have impacted his credit and savings for years.
Build Protection That Works For You
Renters Liability Coverage: Protects You If You Accidentally Cause Damage or Injure Others
If you're renting, liability coverage ensures you're not left paying out-of-pocket if a guest is injured or you accidentally damage someone else's property. Everyday mishaps can become expensive—this coverage can be your financial safeguard.
Replacement Cost Coverage: Replaces Your Belongings With New Ones After a Loss
Standard renters insurance often pays only for the depreciated value of your personal items. Replacement Cost Coverage ensures you can actually replace what you lose—with new items—so you’re not left paying out of pocket after fire, theft, or other covered disasters.
Identity Theft Coverage: Helps Restore Your Life If Someone Steals Your Identity
If your personal information is stolen, you could spend months and thousands of dollars to reclaim your finances and reputation. Identity theft coverage gives renters critical support and resources—so you’re not alone if the worst happens.
Scheduled Personal Property Coverage: Protects High-Value Belongings Beyond Standard Renters Insurance
Valuable items like jewelry, cameras, and instruments are often under-protected by standard renters insurance. This coverage ensures your most important possessions are fully protected—even from accidental loss or worldwide misplacement—giving you true peace of mind.
Medical Payments To Others: Pays Guest Medical Bills If They’re Hurt At Your Rental
If a guest is injured in your rental home, medical payments coverage helps pay their medical bills—no matter who was at fault. It’s peace of mind for the unexpected, so a small accident won’t become a big problem.
Personal Property Coverage: Protects What’s Inside Your Rental When Disaster Strikes
Even if you don’t own your place, your belongings are at risk from theft, fire, and accidents. Renters property coverage ensures your most valued possessions—electronics, furniture, and clothing—are protected from life’s sudden events.
Smart Coverage Based on Your Life Stage
The right renters insurance strategy depends on your current situation, future plans, and what you own.
First Apartment / Recent Graduate
Starting out means balancing affordability with essential protection. Focus on covering your basics plus any specialty items like electronics or musical instruments. Since you're likely budget-conscious, consider higher deductibles ($500-$1,000) to lower monthly premiums to around $14/month.
Smart moves include taking advantage of auto-renters bundling discounts, documenting all possessions with photos, and ensuring your policy covers items in your vehicle.
Established Renter / Couple
As you accumulate higher quality furnishings and possibly share space with a partner, your coverage needs typically increase. Ensure both residents are listed on the policy for complete protection. Consider higher personal property limits ($50,000+) and liability coverage ($300,000+) to protect your growing assets.
Priority considerations include scheduling valuable items like engagement rings or collectibles, adding identity theft protection, and ensuring replacement cost coverage rather than actual cash value.
Luxury Renter / Pre-Homeowner
When renting by choice in upscale properties, comprehensive coverage becomes essential. Your high-end furnishings, electronics, and possibly art or collections require specialized protection. Consider increasing personal property coverage to $75,000+ and liability to $500,000+, possibly with an additional umbrella policy.
Crucial elements include itemizing and appraising valuable collections, ensuring adequate coverage for home office equipment, and selecting guaranteed replacement cost coverage for maximum protection.
The 3-Question Coverage Framework
Ask yourself these three questions for every coverage option:
1. What possessions would be painful to replace?
Take inventory of what you actually own. Most renters underestimate their property value by 40%. Count electronics, furniture, clothing, kitchen items, and hobby equipment. A typical one-bedroom apartment often contains $25,000-$50,000 in personal property.
2. What liability exposures do you have?
Consider your lifestyle and visitors. Dog owners, frequent entertainers, and those with active hobbies face increased liability risks. Remember that you could be responsible for damage to the building caused by negligence (leaving a faucet running, cooking fires).
3. What can you afford to lose?
Your deductible is what you'll pay out-of-pocket before insurance kicks in. Choose a deductible based on what you could comfortably pay in an emergency. Lower deductibles mean higher premiums, while higher deductibles reduce monthly costs but require more savings.
🚩 Red Flags: When "Cheap" Renters Insurance Costs More 🚩
Actual Cash Value (ACV) Instead of Replacement Cost: ACV policies deduct depreciation, meaning your 5-year-old laptop might only be covered for $200 instead of the $1,200 it costs to replace it. Always choose replacement cost coverage.
Inadequate Personal Property Coverage: Most renters underestimate their belongings' value by 40%. Take inventory before selecting limits - replacing everything at once is far more expensive than acquiring items over time.
Minimum Liability Limits: Medical bills and legal fees can easily exceed $100,000. The difference between $100,000 and $300,000 in liability coverage often costs just a few dollars per month but provides substantially more protection.
Missing Additional Living Expenses Coverage: If your rental becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss, where will you stay? Make sure your policy includes adequate coverage for temporary housing and additional costs.
Understanding the Value of Renters Insurance
Renters insurance is one of the most affordable types of protection available, offering substantial financial security for the cost of a streaming service subscription.
Cost Comparisons
Replacing Stolen Electronics:
With renters insurance: $250-$500 (your deductible)
Without coverage: $3,000-$5,000+ (full replacement cost)
Water Damage to Your Belongings:
With renters insurance: $250-$1,000 (deductible)
Without coverage: $8,000-$20,000+ (full replacement cost)
Liability Claim for Guest Injury:
With renters insurance: $0 (covered by your policy)
Without coverage: $25,000-$100,000+ (medical bills and legal expenses)
The Real World
$14-$18 - Average monthly premium for renters insurance. That's less than most people spend on coffee each month for protection against potentially devastating financial losses.
Only 55% of renters carry insurance despite the fact that landlords' policies never cover tenants' personal belongings. This creates significant financial exposure for nearly half of all renters.
$2,661 is the average loss from a burglary incident - but this doesn't include additional costs like temporary security measures or time lost from work.
Claims for water damage, fire, theft, and liability are the most common. These everyday risks affect renters regardless of neighborhood, building type, or economic status.
Protect Your Home & Belongings Today
Join over 1,430 renters who trust our independent advisors to find personalized coverage from 26 top-rated insurance carriers.
FAQs
Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique.