Short-term Disability Insurance: Replaces Income When Illness or Injury Keeps You from Working
If an unexpected illness or injury stops your paycheck, short-term disability insurance ensures you still receive a portion of your income while you recover. It’s how you protect your financial stability from the most common risks working adults face.
When Short-term Disability Insurance Makes the Difference
Real scenarios that show exactly when and how short-term disability insurance protects you.
Minor Surgery—Major Relief
Emma, a graphic designer, needed outpatient knee surgery, leaving her unable to work for three weeks. Her short-term disability insurance paid her 60% of her normal paycheck, covering nearly $2,000 in lost wages. Instead of dipping into savings or falling behind on bills, Emma only worried about recovery and got back to work on schedule.
Unexpected Illness at the Wrong Time
Carlos, a restaurant manager, caught a severe case of pneumonia during peak season, forcing him to miss a month of work. With short-term disability coverage, Carlos received weekly payments replacing most of his lost paycheck—over $3,200 in total. Instead of facing overdue rent and stressful borrowing, Carlos focused on his health and returned to work debt-free.
Major Accident, Full Protection
Alisha, an accountant, was in a car accident that made working impossible for eight weeks. With medical bills and family care weighing heavily, her short-term disability insurance delivered steady income—over $5,000 in total benefits. Instead of facing financial crisis, Alisha paid her mortgage and kept her life on track thanks to her coverage.
Everything You Need to Know About Short-term Disability Insurance
The complete picture: what's covered, what's not, and how to decide if you need it.
Short-term Disability Insurance (Plain English)
Short-term disability insurance is a policy that pays you part of your paycheck when you can’t work due to illness or injury (that isn’t work-related). When your doctor says you need time off, this coverage replaces a percentage of your income for a set number of weeks. The key thing to understand is that it protects your finances during unexpected medical leave.
The Important Details
This coverage usually pays between 50%–70% of your gross income depending on the policy. There’s usually a waiting period (like 7 days) before benefits kick in. Benefits last anywhere from a few weeks up to a maximum (often 12 or 26 weeks). It does not cover work injuries (that’s workers’ comp). Benefits are often reduced by other income you get—check the policy’s offset rules. There’s usually no deductible, but you may have to use sick leave first before coverage begins.
Short-term Disability vs. Workers’ Compensation and Long-term Disability
Short-term disability insurance is NOT the same as workers' compensation or long-term disability. Short-term disability covers you when you can’t work from off-the-job illnesses or injuries, while workers’ compensation covers work injuries and long-term disability is for disabilities expected to last six months or more. You typically need both short-term and long-term disability for complete protection.
Who Needs Short-term Disability Insurance?
You typically need this coverage if:
- You rely on your paycheck to cover rent, mortgage, or bills
- Your employer does not provide a group short-term disability plan
- Your job does not have enough paid sick leave to cover extended absences
You might skip this coverage if:
- You have significant savings and can cover months of expenses out-of-pocket
- Your employer offers generous paid leave that exceeds your risk
Your Options & Limits
Benefit amounts depend on a percentage of your salary and capped weekly maximums—check your plan. Elimination periods commonly range from seven to fourteen days. Benefit durations are set by the plan (often 13–26 weeks). No deductible, but sick or PTO days may be used first. Some plans have optional extras like pregnancy coverage or higher income replacement for extra premium—ask your broker to compare options.
What's NOT Covered by Short-term Disability
This coverage does NOT cover:
- Workplace injuries: These are covered by workers’ compensation
- Long-term or permanent disabilities: You’ll need long-term disability insurance
- Pre-existing conditions: Some policies don’t cover disabilities from conditions you had before the policy started
- Elective procedures: Such as cosmetic surgeries (unless medically necessary)
For these situations, you'd need workers’ compensation, long-term disability, or health insurance.
Ready to Add Short-term Disability Protection?
Now that you understand short-term disability insurance, see how affordable protection can be with personalized quotes from 26+ carriers.
Experience You Can Trust
1,430+ Colorado and Utah clients trust our expertise to explain coverage clearly and find the right protection for their specific needs.
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers, just like you
97% Retention
Customers stay with us year over year over year
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
How Short-term Disability Insurance Actually Works
Understanding exactly what happens when you file a short-term disability claim—from start to finish.
The Claims Process
- Notify Your Employer and Insurer: Let your employer and the insurance company know as soon as you anticipate being out due to illness or injury. They’ll provide claim forms and explain needed documentation (like a doctor’s note).
- Submit Claim and Documentation: Send in required paperwork. Your provider or employer may help you complete forms, and your doctor submits a medical certification.
- Claim Review: The insurer reviews your claim, checks eligibility, and confirms the length of leave. This review often takes a few days to one week.
- Benefit Payments Issued: If approved, payments begin after the waiting period and continue weekly, replacing a set portion of your income until you’re able to return to work or you reach the plan’s limit.
What You Pay
Premiums for short-term disability insurance vary based on your income, job type, and group plan structure—typically $10–$40/month if you pay. There’s rarely a deductible, but you may use paid sick days first. The premium ensures you have access to replacement income when you need it most.
Timeline
Simple claims (like scheduled surgeries) usually start paying benefits in 7–14 days and run through recovery, typically 6–12 weeks. Complex claims (with medical reviews or overlapping leave) may take an extra week or two to resolve. Most clients see prompt, reliable payments as long as paperwork is complete. The key is early reporting—the sooner you start, the faster benefits begin.
The Real Cost of Going Without Short-term Disability Insurance
Understanding the real financial impact: what you pay for coverage vs. what you risk without it.
Minor Surgery Recovery
Annual Coverage Cost: $180
Scenario: Missed 3 weeks for outpatient knee surgery
Without Coverage: $2,250 lost income
With Coverage: $0 (60% of income replaced, premiums already paid)
Protection Value: $2,250 saved in one event
Flu or Virus Outbreak
Annual Coverage Cost: $240
Scenario: Missed 4 weeks for serious illness
Without Coverage: $3,000 lost income
With Coverage: $0 (weekly benefit covers income gap)
Protection Value: $3,000 protected
Major Accident
Annual Coverage Cost: $360
Scenario: 8 weeks unable to work due to an off-the-job injury
Without Coverage: $6,000 lost income
With Coverage: $0 (up to policy weekly maximum backed by coverage)
Protection Value: $6,000 secure
The Economic Reality
For most people, short-term disability insurance costs $15–$30 per month—less than a weekly takeout order. One incident without coverage could leave you with $2,000–$8,000 in lost income, which could take years to recover from financially. The math is simple: short-term disability pays for itself the first time you need it and protects your lifestyle and financial stability from common, everyday risks.
4 Costly Short-term Disability Insurance Mistakes to Avoid
Learn from others' mistakes—avoid these common errors that can leave you unprotected when you need coverage most.
Assuming Your Employer Provides It
Many employees think short-term disability is included by default, but many employers do not offer this coverage. Without it, you’re at risk of unpaid leave. Instead, verify your benefits and consider individual coverage if it’s not included.
Believing Workers' Comp Covers Everything
Some believe any work absence qualifies for workers’ compensation. Workers’ comp covers only job-related injuries or illnesses. For most common sicknesses and accidents, only short-term disability pays out. Review your coverage types to avoid surprises.
Underestimating How Long Recovery Takes
Clients sometimes buy coverage with the shortest benefit period to lower costs, only to discover recovery takes longer—especially after surgery or illness relapses. Choosing the shortest benefit could leave you out of income before you’re ready to work again. Instead, select a benefit period that truly matches your risk.
Not Understanding Waiting Periods
People are often caught off-guard by the waiting period before benefits start (usually 7 or 14 days). If you have no savings, this can cause financial stress. Instead, plan for the gap and keep some emergency savings for those first missed days.
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.
Explore Your Coverage Options
Discover the best insurance coverage tailored to your individual needs and protect what matters most.