Can independent contractors be covered under my commercial auto policy?
Yes, independent contractors can often be covered if listed as drivers on your commercial auto policy, or you may require them to carry their own insurance. Check with your insurer to ensure compliance with Colorado or Utah regulations.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance partner, providing peace of mind and clarity through expert guidance.
Complete Guide to Covering Independent Contractors Under Your Commercial Auto Policy
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
For businesses in Colorado and Utah—especially those in fast-growing areas like Fort Collins, Denver, and Salt Lake City—the way you cover drivers impacts your legal exposure, claims outcomes, and financial security. Understanding who is (and isn't) protected under your commercial auto policy can be the difference between business continuity and expensive, uncovered losses.
- Legal Compliance: Both Colorado and Utah require strict adherence to vehicle insurance statutes. Mistakes (like failing to list a contractor-driver) often mean claims are denied or fines are imposed.
- Growing Gig & Contractor Workforce: The rise of gig commerce and project-based work—common in metro Denver, Boulder, and Salt Lake—means more businesses rely on non-employee drivers. Each contractor's insurance status affects business risk.
- High Value of Claims: Average commercial auto claim costs in Northern Colorado exceed $42,000 for collisions and $8,750 for hail damage; uninsured losses can exceed $218,000 per incident, underlining why clarity is crucial.
What Most People Get Wrong
Many business owners think their standard commercial auto policy automatically covers anyone driving their vehicles—including contractors. In reality, unless independent contractors are explicitly listed as drivers or your policy contains the correct non-owned vehicle endorsements, coverage may not apply. This mistake is especially common with delivery, construction, and home service companies in Colorado and Utah.
Another misconception: believing that if a contractor has “any” insurance, it’s enough. State requirements can differ, and the contractor’s own policy may not meet your business’s protection needs or liability minimums.
The Complete Picture
Independent contractors can be covered under your commercial auto insurance in Colorado and Utah if you list them as regular drivers on your policy and your insurer approves the arrangement. Otherwise, you’ll need to require contractors to carry their own commercial auto insurance—and verify that their coverage matches your business’s liability standards and includes sufficient limits (experts recommend $1M combined single limit as Colorado courts see frequent six-figure judgements).
Remember: Colorado’s modified comparative fault system and Utah's liability statutes can make your business responsible for damages caused by contractors using company vehicles—even if they are not formal employees—especially after recent court decisions. For true protection, work closely with your insurer and update your driver lists regularly. Many local insurers also provide non-owned auto liability coverage for businesses that hire independent contractors who supply their own vehicles. This endorsement can fill the gap, protecting your business from claims involving vehicles your company does not own but are used for your business purposes.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: Do I Need to List Independent Contractors as Drivers?
Deciding whether to add contractors to your policy or require their own insurance depends on:
- The nature of their work (e.g., are they using company vans or personal vehicles?)
- Your ability to update your policy regularly and verify their insurance status
- State regulations—Colorado often holds companies liable for damages, even if the driver is a contractor
Question 2: Have I Documented Proof of Coverage and Compliance?
Protect your business by keeping records of all contractors’ insurance certificates (if they carry their own), or documented endorsements with their names if covered under your policy. This is especially important in claims situations and routine audits in high-risk metro areas like Denver, Fort Collins, and Salt Lake City.
Question 3: How Will Future Business Changes Affect My Coverage?
Will you add more vehicles, expand into new territory, or take on new types of drivers? Consider how a changing workforce (more gig workers or expansion across I-25 or I-15 corridors) impacts your insurance needs. Set up annual policy reviews with a local FoCoIns advisor to keep protection up to date as your business evolves.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
Fort Collins Delivery Service: Contractor in a Company Van
Background: Alex operates a courier business in Fort Collins that frequently hires independent drivers—like Maria—during peak delivery times. Maria drives a company-owned van on assigned routes.
Coverage: The business made sure to list Maria as an occasional driver on the commercial auto policy with $1 million liability coverage, $500 deductibles for comprehensive/collision, and hail endorsements.
Monthly Premium: $162/month ($1,944/year)
The Incident: During a rainy April day on Harmony Road, Maria was involved in a minor collision with damages totaling $12,000. The company’s policy covered repairs and a rental van, minus the deductible.
Total Claim Cost: $12,000 (vehicle repairs and loss of use)
Maria's Cost: $0 (business paid the deductible as part of employment agreement)
"It was a big relief knowing Maria was correctly listed on our policy—everything was handled quickly, and our business kept moving." — Alex
Salt Lake City Gig Worker: Separate Insurance Required
Background: Tyler picks up contract delivery gigs in Salt Lake City, using his own pickup for work with multiple companies.
Coverage: Each business required proof that Tyler carried commercial auto insurance with at least $500,000 liability. Tyler’s monthly cost for the policy was $87/month ($1,044/year).
The Incident: While delivering construction materials on I-15 near downtown, Tyler was rear-ended. After the claim, his own insurance handled repairs and medical bills.
Total Claim Cost: $9,200 (vehicle repair and minor injury)
Tyler's Cost: $500 (policy deductible)
"Having my own commercial policy kept me covered while working for different companies—no confusion, no drama." — Tyler
Boulder Contractor: Policy Oversight Causes Denied Claim
Background: Sara manages a small moving company in Boulder. She assumed her independent helper Eli would be covered when driving a company box truck, but never added him to the policy.
Coverage: The company’s policy had $500,000 liability limits, but only listed full-time employees as drivers.
Monthly Premium: $151/month ($1,812/year)
The Incident: Eli was in a fender-bender downtown. When the claim was filed, the insurer denied the loss due to Eli not being a listed driver.
Total Claim Cost: $6,500 (uncovered repair and rental costs)
Sara's Cost: $6,500 (out-of-pocket, unrecoverable by insurance)
"Missing that small detail cost us a huge chunk of our operating budget—lesson learned: always double-check your driver list!" — Sara
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Assuming Anyone Driving a Company Vehicle Is Automatically Covered
What People Do: Letting independent contractors, temporary workers, or helpers use business vehicles without formally listing them on the policy.
Why It Seems Logical: Many owners believe “if it’s my van and my policy, anyone I authorize is covered.”
The Real Cost: In Colorado and Utah, unlisted drivers often mean denied claims—potentially costing you the full amount of an accident (average $42,000+ per collision).
Smart Alternative: Work with FoCoIns to review and update your policy before contractors drive. Ensure all regular drivers are named, and ask about endorsements for occasional or non-owned vehicle use.
Mistake #2: Relying on Contractors' Personal Insurance Without Verification
What People Do: Trusting contractors’ word or a quick look at their insurance card, without reviewing evidence of active, sufficiently rated commercial coverage.
Why It Seems Logical: It’s easier and cheaper to “assume” coverage than request and track certificates, especially for short-term gigs.
The Real Cost: If the contractor’s policy lapses, excludes business use, or has low limits, your business could be held liable for uninsured losses—risking $218,000 or more per serious claim in Northern Colorado courts.
Smart Alternative: Require up-to-date certificates listing your business as an additional insured, and work with a FoCoIns advisor to audit documents annually or before key projects.
Mistake #3: Carrying Only State Minimum Liability for Contractor-Driven Commercial Vehicles
What People Do: Choosing 25/50/15 minimums “to save money,” unaware that commercial claims often exceed $100,000.
Why It Seems Logical: Required minimums sound easier to meet and keep premiums lower—until something happens.
The Real Cost: Minimum liability rarely protects you in court—Colorado and Utah judges frequently award six-figure settlements. One major claim can bankrupt a business and force closure (64% of underinsured companies fold within a year of major claims).
Smart Alternative: FoCoIns recommends at least $500,000–$1 million in coverage for any vehicles driven by contractors. This modest premium increase buys true peace of mind and business continuity.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.