What happens if my employee has an accident in a company vehicle?
If your employee has an accident in a company vehicle during authorized business use, your commercial auto insurance typically covers the damages—including liability and repairs—subject to your policy limits and deductibles.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance partner, providing peace of mind and expert local guidance for business owners.
Complete Guide to Employee Accidents in Company Vehicles
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
For business owners in Colorado and Utah, employees are often behind the wheel—delivering goods in Denver, servicing clients in Salt Lake City, or hauling equipment across the Front Range. When an employee is in an accident, the financial and legal stakes can be significant. With Colorado ranking first in vehicle thefts and second in hail losses, and with growing business density in both states, understanding how your commercial auto policy responds is crucial for protecting your business, financial health, and reputation.
- Legal Responsibility: State laws in both Colorado and Utah hold businesses liable for damages caused by employees acting within the scope of their job duties.
- High Regional Risks: Elevated accident rates along I-25 and I-15, frequent hail events, and urban vehicle theft mean claims are not just possible—they’re likely.
- Business Survival: With the average liability claim exceeding $218,000 in Colorado and more than 60% of underinsured businesses closing within a year of a major loss, the right coverage is essential.
What Most People Get Wrong
Misconception #1: Many believe state minimum coverage is sufficient for commercial use. In reality, basic limits often fall drastically short after a serious accident involving injuries or multiple vehicles.
Misconception #2: Business owners sometimes assume personal auto policies will cover incidents if employees use company vehicles for errands—most of the time, these claims are denied if the policy is not specifically for business use or if unauthorized drivers are involved.
The Complete Picture
Your commercial auto insurance policy is designed to cover accidents involving your employees, as long as the vehicle was being used for authorized business purposes. Coverage typically includes bodily injury, property damage, medical payments, and legal defense for your business if you’re sued. For example, in Colorado the average premium is around $1,800 per vehicle annually, but actual costs and coverage depend on your business and vehicle types.
Policy specifics matter: If an employee was driving for business but violated company policy (such as using the vehicle for personal side jobs), or if you failed to properly list all potential drivers, the insurer may reduce or deny coverage. Claims must be reported promptly—delay can result in lost benefits under Colorado’s and Utah’s prompt payment laws. Working with a local, independent broker ensures your coverage aligns with regional risks like hail and theft, common in Colorado and Utah, and evolving regulations. Always clarify expectations with your employees (authorized use, accident response), and review your policy details at least annually to adapt to business growth, changes in staff, or new vehicles.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: Are My Employees and Vehicles Properly Listed and Covered?
Failure to list all drivers or accurately classify vehicle usage (delivery, construction, consulting) can lead to denied claims or severe coverage gaps. Be proactive:
- Review all drivers—employees, part-timers, and contractors.
- Update usage, territory (such as Denver urban vs. rural Utah), and business purposes with your broker.
Question 2: Do My Liability Limits Reflect Real Regional Risks?
State minimums don’t reflect reality in Colorado’s and Utah’s legal and accident environment. With average liability claims exceeding $218,000 and commercial auto lawsuits on the rise, consider limits of at least $500,000, scaling to $1 million for transportation, contracting, or fleet operations. Real-world events—such as hail losses averaging $8,750 or multi-vehicle collisions on I-25—make higher limits a smart investment.
Question 3: Are My Employees Trained and Informed About Proper Vehicle Use?
Train all drivers on winter driving, hail response, and company protocol. Clear written policies about authorized vehicle use, immediate claim reporting, and what to do if an accident occurs (police report, documentation) help prevent costly errors. Involve your insurance advisor in staff training for best results.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
Delivery Mishap in Fort Collins, CO
Background: Amy, who works for a local bakery on Harmony Road in Fort Collins, uses a company van to deliver cakes across town.
Coverage: Commercial auto policy with $1 million liability, comprehensive, collision, and medical payments.
Monthly Premium: $150/month ($1,800/year)
The Incident: While merging onto College Avenue, Amy accidentally rear-ends another vehicle. There are minor injuries and moderate vehicle damage.
Total Claim Cost: $46,500 (Bodily injury: $16,000; Property damage: $30,500)
Amy's Cost: $1,000 deductible – all medical/legal costs handled by the policy.
"I was shaken up, but knowing our company’s insurance handled everything quickly let me focus on recovering instead of worrying about the bakery’s future."
Winter Slide in Salt Lake City, UT
Background: Mark, a plumbing company employee in Salt Lake City, is dispatched in a company van to a customer’s home during a snowstorm.
Coverage: Utah commercial auto policy, $500,000 liability, comprehensive with winter weather extension, uninsured motorist.
Monthly Premium: $145/month ($1,740/year)
The Incident: Mark hits a patch of ice on a steep residential street in Sugar House, sliding into a parked car and causing significant damage.
Total Claim Cost: $17,500 (Repairs to both vehicles, minor injury claim by other driver)
Mark's Cost: $1,000 deductible; company covered the rest.
"If our boss hadn’t invested in good insurance and made us take winter driving training, I don’t know how I would have managed. The process was straightforward, and we didn’t lose business."
Theft Incident Near Denver, CO
Background: Luis owns a landscaping business based in Lakewood (Denver metro) and employs two drivers for his fleet.
Coverage: $1 million liability, comprehensive with theft and hail endorsements, uninsured motorist.
Monthly Premium: $170/month ($2,040/year)
The Incident: One morning, a company truck is found missing from a site off Colfax Avenue. It was reported stolen overnight.
Total Claim Cost: $34,200 (Replacement value of stolen truck)
Luis's Cost: $1,500 deductible – replacement truck covered in full, little to no business interruption.
"As a small business owner, I feared one theft could ruin us. Because FoCoIns had us fully covered and explained everything in advance, we bounced back within days."
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Relying on State Minimum Liability Limits
What People Do: Choose the lowest legal limit (25/50/15 in Colorado) to save on premiums, not realizing what’s at stake.
Why It Seems Logical: Lower limits mean lower monthly costs, and many believe accidents are rare or always small.
The Real Cost: A major injury claim or multi-vehicle pile-up along I-25 or I-15 can easily exceed $200,000. The business is personally responsible for all damages above the insurance limit, which could mean bankruptcy or closure. 64% of underinsured Colorado businesses close within a year of a major loss.
Smart Alternative: Set liability at $500,000-$1,000,000 and consult with a FoCoIns broker for a risk assessment. The premium difference can be modest compared to the catastrophic risk of underinsurance.
Mistake #2: Failing to List All Drivers
What People Do: Assign vehicles to "main" employees but allow part-time, seasonal, or even relatives to drive without updating the policy.
Why It Seems Logical: Small businesses assume the policy covers any occasional user as long as the company owns the vehicle.
The Real Cost: During a claim investigation, if an unlisted employee causes an accident, the carrier may deny coverage, leaving the business with the full claim amount—commonly $20,000–$50,000 or more in repairs, liability, and legal costs.
Smart Alternative: Regularly update your driver roster with your FoCoIns advisor. Build a culture of full disclosure for anyone who may drive a company vehicle—protection always outweighs minor premium changes.
Mistake #3: Allowing Unauthorized Use or Side Jobs
What People Do: Let employees use company vehicles for personal errands or side jobs, or skip regular training on proper business usage.
Why It Seems Logical: Trusting employees and wanting to be flexible feels supportive, and off-hours use isn’t seen as risky.
The Real Cost: Claims arising from personal use or unauthorized side gigs are often denied. In Colorado and Utah, this means full out-of-pocket responsibility for accidents, often $10,000–$100,000+ and potential legal action if injuries are involved.
Smart Alternative: Make a written policy restricting company vehicle use to authorized business only, and train all staff accordingly. FoCoIns can help draft guidelines and recommend regular training for compliance and safety.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.