What is cyber extortion coverage?
Cyber extortion coverage protects your business if hackers demand payment to avoid or stop a cyber attack, covering ransom payments, negotiation, and related expenses. This coverage can be crucial, as the average ransomware demand in Colorado and Utah now exceeds $187,000.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance partner, providing peace of mind through expert guidance.
Complete Guide to Cyber Extortion Coverage
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
Cyber attacks are on the rise, and Colorado and Utah small businesses are prime targets due to rapid growth and increasingly digital operations. With the average ransomware attack in these states costing $187,000 and only 31% of local businesses carrying cyber liability insurance, understanding cyber extortion coverage is more important than ever.
- High Cost of Attacks: Cyber criminals have intensified their efforts, especially targeting professional services, healthcare, and tech businesses in Front Range cities and along Utah's Wasatch Front. Ransomware demands in our region are routinely in the six-figure range, with the average cyber event costing $187,000 in 2023.
- Gaps in Standard Policies: Most standard commercial property and general liability policies do not cover cyber extortion events or ransom demands, leaving businesses vulnerable unless they add this specialized coverage.
- Increasing Regulatory Pressure: Colorado and Utah have tightened rules for protecting and reporting on client data. Some industries now require minimum $1M in breach response coverage.
What Most People Get Wrong
Many business owners in Colorado and Utah think strong IT security alone will prevent cyber extortion incidents. While security is critical, 2023 regional stats show that even companies with robust controls face successful attacks—especially social engineering and third-party vendor breaches.
Another misconception is that cyber coverage is too expensive or will never be needed. But with projected cyber premiums rising 35-50% in 2025 and claims more common than fire losses, skipping this protection can be far more costly long-term.
The Complete Picture
Cyber extortion coverage is a part of a commercial cyber liability insurance policy that pays for costs associated with cybercriminal demands—for example, when hackers threaten to release sensitive data, disrupt operations, or lock you out of critical systems until a ransom is paid. It covers:
- Ransom Payments (within policy limits)
- Negotiation and Investigation costs—engaging cyber experts, forensic investigators, and legal counsel to deal with the threat and coordinate with law enforcement
- System Restoration and Data Recovery if data is encrypted or compromised
- Incident Response—regulatory fines, customer notifications, and public relations if necessary
For many Colorado and Utah businesses, this coverage is the difference between a manageable disruption and a devastating financial loss. With regulatory changes, many healthcare and financial firms are now required to carry cyber extortion and breach response coverage of at least $1 million. As cyber threats grow, insurers are also tightening underwriting—so a strong risk management program can help you qualify for broader coverage at better rates.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: Does my business handle sensitive information or operate online in a way that could make me a target?
Consider whether you store customer credit cards, health information, or other critical data, or if your operations rely on digital systems.
- Healthcare providers, law offices, and retailers in Fort Collins, Denver, Salt Lake City, and Provo are frequent targets due to valuable client data.
- Even small construction firms bidding online or managing payroll digitally are at risk.
Question 2: What level of coverage is required for my industry or by my clients?
Many contracts and industry regulations (especially in health and finance) now require at least $500,000–$1,000,000 in cyber liability/response coverage to win or keep business in Colorado and Utah.
Question 3: Have I reviewed my current risk controls and coverage limits for cyber attacks?
Ask your advisor to review your risk controls (IT, policies, employee training). Insurers now reward stronger cybersecurity with lower premiums and broader coverage—sometimes saving clients 10–20%. Not sure if you're adequately protected? FoCoIns can provide a tailored assessment for your specific industry and location.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
Tech Firm Faces Ransomware in Fort Collins
Background: Anna runs a 10-person software startup on Harmony Road in Fort Collins. The company stores client project files and billing info on cloud-based systems.
Coverage: $1M cyber liability policy—including $500,000 cyber extortion coverage, $2,800 annual premium
Monthly Premium: $233/month ($2,800/year)
The Incident: Hackers encrypted all servers and demanded $120,000 in bitcoin to prevent data from being leaked online.
Total Claim Cost: $137,000 ($120,000 ransom + $17,000 forensic, legal, and data recovery fees)
Anna's Cost: $5,000 (policy deductible—the insurer handled everything else, including expert negotiators)
"I never imagined a small company in Fort Collins could be a target—but without this coverage, we would have shut down. The claims team handled everything and got us back online fast."
Healthcare Breach in Salt Lake City
Background: Brian manages a mid-size dental practice along South Temple Street in Salt Lake City, holding thousands of patient records and x-rays.
Coverage: $2M cyber liability with $1M extortion limit, $4,600 annual premium
Monthly Premium: $383/month ($4,600/year)
The Incident: Cyber criminals threatened to leak confidential patient records unless $200,000 was paid. They simultaneously locked the clinic’s booking system, effectively halting operations.
Total Claim Cost: $225,000 ($200,000 ransom + $25,000 crisis, forensic, and patient notification expenses)
Brian's Cost: $10,000 (the deductible—policy covered the rest including expert negotiators and PR consultants)
"We always thought of cyber insurance as a nice-to-have. When crisis struck, it saved our business and our reputation."
Retailer Ransom Attempt in Boulder
Background: Mia owns an outdoor equipment store near Pearl Street in Boulder, using a point-of-sale system and online ordering platform connecting to inventory records.
Coverage: $500,000 cyber extortion rider on a broader commercial policy, $1,500 annual premium
Monthly Premium: $125/month ($1,500/year)
The Incident: Hackers threatened to flood the business’s Google reviews with fake one-star ratings and post sensitive supplier data unless paid $25,000. Mia reported the incident to the insurer’s cyber team.
Total Claim Cost: $7,300 ($0 ransom paid—the specialist team resolved the issue; $7,300 for cyber response services, IT system audits, and public relations)
Mia's Cost: $1,000 (deductible; rapid specialist response avoided any ransom and reputational damage)
"The insurer's experts took over and reassured my staff and customers. I didn’t pay a dime in ransom, and we even got fraudulent reviews removed."
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Assuming IT Security Alone is Enough
What People Do: Rely solely on strong passwords, firewalls, and IT professionals, skipping dedicated cyber extortion coverage.
Why It Seems Logical: Good security seems like a strong deterrent and a worthy expense for any business.
The Real Cost: Even well-protected Colorado and Utah businesses face attacks. Without proper coverage, out-of-pocket ransom costs average $187,000 per event, plus legal and system recovery expenses—expenses that no IT plan can guarantee will be avoided.
Smart Alternative: Layer cyber extortion insurance with your IT strategy. FoCoIns helps you balance strong cybersecurity with back-up financial protection and rapid expert response.
Mistake #2: Choosing the Lowest-Cost/Limited Cyber Policy
What People Do: Opt for the cheapest cyber policy, often with minimal extortion limits or high deductibles, just to check a box for clients or compliance.
Why It Seems Logical: Cyber coverage costs are rising and saving on premiums feels prudent when claims seem unlikely.
The Real Cost: Recent CO/UT claims show ransoms and crisis response expenses often exceed standard $50k or $100k policy limits—leaving the business responsible for the excess. This can mean tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars in uninsured costs.
Smart Alternative: Work with a knowledgeable advisor like FoCoIns to match coverage limits and deductibles to your real exposure—especially if larger contracts specify minimum coverage for cyber events.
Mistake #3: Believing Cyber Extortion is Only a Risk for Big Businesses
What People Do: Small and medium businesses in places like Greeley or Logan skip cyber extortion coverage, believing they're too small to interest hackers.
Why It Seems Logical: Media stories focus on headline-grabbing breaches at large companies, creating a false sense of security for Main Street operations.
The Real Cost: Over 60% of ransomware victims in recent Colorado and Utah stats are small businesses. Attackers often target smaller firms precisely because they lack in-house security and resources—making them easy, profitable targets.
Smart Alternative: Regardless of size, every business needs cyber extortion protection. FoCoIns specializes in right-sized cyber solutions, tailored for organizations big and small throughout Colorado and Utah.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.