What is social engineering fraud, and is it covered?
Social engineering fraud is when criminals trick employees into transferring funds or revealing confidential data—often via email scams. Coverage is not standard and usually requires a special endorsement on your policy.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance partner, providing expert guidance for local businesses navigating cyber risks.
Complete Guide to Social Engineering Fraud Coverage
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
Businesses in Colorado and Utah face a rising threat from social engineering fraud, with regional tech firms, real estate brokers, and non-profits all seeing increased scam attempts. Many believe cyber fraud is automatically covered by commercial insurance—but that’s rarely the case in our region’s challenging risk environment. Knowing the truth can save thousands.
- Regional Threats Rising: The average cost of a business-targeted ransomware attack in Colorado is $187,000, but less than a third of local businesses carry comprehensive cyber insurance addressing social engineering scams.
- Industry Targets: Startups in Boulder, Salt Lake City property managers, and Northern Colorado non-profits are all recent victims of email scams, highlighting the wide reach of these attacks.
- Customized Coverage Needed: Standard commercial crime or cyber policies rarely include social engineering (funds transfer) fraud unless specifically endorsed—and these gaps have led to costly uncovered losses for local firms.
What Most People Get Wrong
A common misconception is that cyber or general crime coverage automatically protects against any kind of scam. In reality, most policies exclude voluntary transfers—even when employees are tricked by convincing fake emails or calls. Furthermore, many are unaware that endorsements for social engineering fraud exist but require specific negotiation and higher premiums.
Assuming that all incidents involving computers or fraud are insured leads to significant coverage gaps. It’s essential to review individual policy limits, retroactive coverage dates, and vendor contract requirements to avoid unexpected denials after a loss.
The Complete Picture
Social engineering fraud involves scammers using psychological tricks—like bogus emails, calls, or texts—to fool employees into sending money or sensitive information. Phishing, spear phishing, and CEO impersonation attacks are increasingly sophisticated in Colorado and Utah. Standard commercial insurance policies (including commercial crime and cyber) often exclude these losses unless a social engineering fraud endorsement is added. Even with such coverage, specific sublimits, deductibles, and strict notification requirements may apply.
Given that only about 31% of Colorado businesses carry standalone cyber or social engineering coverage, local business owners should consult an independent broker to assess risk and secure appropriate endorsements. Consider practical steps like employee training, robust payment verification procedures, and regularly updating coverage—especially as scams evolve and target new industries across our region.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: Does my current policy address social engineering fraud?
Review your policy documents or consult your agent to determine if a specific endorsement exists for social engineering, phishing, or funds transfer fraud. Look closely for these terms—not all "cyber" or "crime" coverage is created equal.
- Check for exclusions regarding voluntary funds transfer or impersonation scams.
- Ask if there are sublimits (e.g., $50,000 per event) and separate deductibles.
Question 2: Have my employees received training to recognize scams?
Most successful frauds result from human error, not IT failure. Implement regular, locally relevant training (ideally using examples from recent Colorado and Utah scams).
- Simulate phishing attempts and review payment procedures for verification.
- Update procedures after any near-miss or actual incident.
Question 3: Am I prepared for evolving threats specific to my industry?
Regional trends show that tech startups, real estate brokers, and non-profits are top targets. As these scams grow more sophisticated, review your coverage and risk management practices annually to ensure you’re aligned with industry and regional benchmarks.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
Boulder Startup Falls for Phishing, Learns Costly Lesson
Background: Maya, the CFO of a growing Boulder tech startup, received an urgent email that looked exactly like it came from her CEO, requesting a $64,000 wire transfer to a new supplier.
Coverage: The company's standard commercial crime policy, with no social engineering fraud endorsement.
Monthly Premium: $229/month ($2,748/year)
The Incident: Maya followed payment protocols but didn't catch the fake sender address. The funds left the company account before IT flagged the fraud. Law enforcement traced the scam overseas but couldn't recover the loss.
Total Claim Cost: $64,000 (funds lost; no recovery)
Maya's Cost: $64,000 – Insurance denied the claim since social engineering scams were excluded by policy.
"If I had known our policy didn't cover email scams, I would have insisted on stronger protection. The loss was devastating—but it taught us to review coverage details and get everyone trained."
Salt Lake City Property Managers Saved by Right Endorsement
Background: Ben and Lisa run a property management company in downtown Salt Lake City. One Friday, Ben got an email—supposedly from their largest client—requesting a $41,500 rent disbursement to a "new account." Suspicious, he double-checked internally and realized it was a scam.
Coverage: Crime policy with a $100,000 social engineering fraud endorsement
Monthly Premium: $412/month ($4,944/year)
The Incident: Even with internal checks, a replacement staff member later processed a similar fraudulent request, resulting in a $29,200 wire transfer.
Total Claim Cost: $29,200 (fraudulent transfer; $2,500 deductible)
Ben and Lisa's Cost: $2,500 – The claim was approved and reimbursed after documentation, minus the deductible.
"If we hadn't had the endorsement, we would have been out almost $30,000. Our broker made sure we had protection for exactly this kind of scam—worth every penny."
Fort Collins Non-Profit Misses the Fine Print
Background: Julie directs a Fort Collins non-profit. She responded to what looked like an urgent request from her board chair to approve a $7,800 payment to a new vendor.
Coverage: Basic commercial package policy—no cyber or social engineering fraud coverage
Monthly Premium: $167/month ($2,004/year)
The Incident: The email was a scam. By the time the CFO discovered the fraud, the money was gone and unrecoverable.
Total Claim Cost: $7,800 (entire loss unrecoverable)
Julie's Cost: $7,800 – Claim denied as social engineering was explicitly excluded, and there was no cyber endorsement.
"We assumed our insurance had us covered for ‘hacker scams’. Now we know to check our policy language and ask about endorsements specific to social engineering. It’s not automatic protection."
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Assuming Standard Policies Cover Social Engineering Scams
What People Do: Business owners believe that either their commercial crime or cyber policy automatically insures them for all types of fraud, including wire scams and phishing.
Why It Seems Logical: The language around "fraud" or "cyber" in standard policy brochures is broad and reassuring but rarely details exclusions for voluntary fund transfers due to deception.
The Real Cost: Out-of-pocket losses can range from $7,500 to over $100,000 per event. In Colorado, losses average $187,000 for significant cyber incidents—often with no insurance reimbursement unless a social engineering endorsement was purchased.
Smart Alternative: Work with a broker who explains every exclusion and helps add specific social engineering endorsements that align with your risks. FoCoIns always reviews these details in plain language for every client.
Mistake #2: Overlooking Required Endorsements and Limits
What People Do: Businesses either neglect to add the social engineering fraud endorsement or select very low sublimits ($10,000–$25,000) that don't reflect actual risk levels.
Why It Seems Logical: Premium costs increase for each endorsement, and businesses hesitate to spend more upfront, assuming "that’ll never happen to us."
The Real Cost: When a scam hits, sublimits are exhausted quickly, and claims exceeding the limit become the responsibility of the insured. A $50,000 scam with only $10,000 of coverage leaves you paying $40,000 or more out of pocket.
Smart Alternative: Calculate real-world risk based on your transaction amounts and industry scams in Colorado and Utah. FoCoIns provides custom consultations to set limits reflecting your true exposures, including sector benchmarks and recent local claims.
Mistake #3: Ignoring Policy Dates and Notification Deadlines
What People Do: After discovering a scam, businesses try to file claims months later or worse, during policy renewal, without realizing many policies have strict reporting deadlines and retroactive coverage limitations.
Why It Seems Logical: It’s easy to assume any loss during a policy period should be covered, regardless of when it’s discovered.
The Real Cost: A missed deadline can void coverage entirely—many social engineering endorsements require notification within 30–60 days of discovery. In both Colorado and Utah, denial for late notice is a common outcome.
Smart Alternative: Know your policy’s notification and retroactive dates. Respond immediately after a suspected scam and inform both your insurer and broker without delay. FoCoIns clients receive proactive reminders and claims assistance to help avoid costly denial for late reporting.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.