What is not covered by cyber liability insurance?
Cyber liability insurance in Colorado and Utah typically excludes pre-existing breaches, intentional acts by insiders, and incidents caused by failing to follow basic security practices. Regular security updates and employee training are essential to help ensure coverage when you need it most.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance advisor, providing expertise to protect your business from the unexpected.
Complete Guide to Cyber Liability Insurance Exclusions
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
Understanding what cyber liability insurance does not cover is just as important as knowing what it does—especially in a digital-first economy. Colorado and Utah businesses face rising cyber threats, including ransomware attacks that averaged $187,000 in damages per incident statewide in 2023. Despite these risks, only about 31% of businesses in the region carry standalone cyber policies, meaning many are exposed to uncovered losses.
- Regional Risk: Colorado’s Front Range and Utah’s Wasatch corridor are targets for ransomware and data theft due to a high number of SMBs and tech startups.
- Legal Requirements: Healthcare and financial firms face legal mandates for certain data breach coverages, but these still have exclusions businesses must manage proactively.
- Mitigating Claims Denials: With premiums rising 35-50% annually, ensuring your claim isn’t denied due to preventable exclusions is critical to business survival and resilience in places like Fort Collins and Salt Lake City.
What Most People Get Wrong
A common misconception is that cyber liability insurance is “catch-all” protection for anything digital. In practice, insurers impose exclusions to incentivize basic cybersecurity hygiene and responsible management.
Another frequent misunderstanding is overlooking the significance of cyber incident timing and intent—pre-existing issues are not covered, and insider threats are typically excluded. Failing to maintain up-to-date security systems can easily void claims, leaving businesses dangerously exposed.
The Complete Picture
Cyber liability policies are built to protect against a broad array of digital threats, but every policy includes important exclusions:
- Pre-Existing Breaches: Incidents that started before your policy went into effect are rarely, if ever, covered. This means if a breach is discovered after your coverage begins but started earlier, the claim may be denied.
- Intentional or Criminal Acts by Insiders: Losses caused by employees or business partners acting deliberately or with fraud are generally excluded. These risk factors are viewed as manageable through better hiring, monitoring, and training.
- Failure to Maintain Cybersecurity: If you neglect updates, forgo antivirus requirements, or disregard best practices, insurers can deny claims due to “failure to follow minimum protective measures.”
With average breach costs at $187,000 locally, claims denials can deal a fatal blow to small businesses—especially since cyber insurance claims are scrutinized closely for these exclusions in both Colorado and Utah. That’s why documented compliance, regular employee training, and periodic coverage reviews are vital to maintaining robust protection.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: Are our core security measures documented and up to date?
Confirm you meet insurer requirements for software updates, firewalls, and data backup protocols.
- Audit all systems quarterly and save evidence of updates and employee training.
- Ask your FoCoIns advisor for a checklist tailored to your industry’s risk level and regulatory requirements (especially for healthcare or finance).
Question 2: Have we reviewed our policy exclusions with a local expert?
Many exclusions are hidden in policy fine print. Schedule a review with a Colorado or Utah-based FoCoIns advisor to identify specific gaps or requirements.
Question 3: How will we respond to a claim denial?
Develop a written cyber incident response plan. In places like Boulder, Fort Collins, or Salt Lake City, collaborate with local IT providers and legal resources to ensure your business can quickly present compliance documentation and appeal coverage denials if needed.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
Ransomware After a Missed Update – Harmony Road, Fort Collins
Background: Jamie owns a boutique design agency near Harmony Road in Fort Collins, with 7 employees and frequent client file exchanges.
Coverage: $1 million cyber liability policy with $5,000 deductible, monthly premium $85 ($1,020/year)
The Incident: A critical Windows update was left unapplied for 8 months. Hackers exploited this gap, installing ransomware and encrypting client files.
Total Claim Cost: $96,000 (for decryption, IT forensics, and client notification)
Jamie's Cost: Full $96,000.
The insurer denied the claim because the policy required proof of timely system patching, which wasn’t available.
"I never thought a routine update could bankrupt my business. If I had known the policy required it, I would have set up reminders and training."
Inside Job, No Coverage – Downtown Salt Lake City
Background: Sarah runs a co-working space on Main Street, Salt Lake City. She has a $2 million cyber liability policy at $175/month ($2,100/year).
The Incident: A tech contractor, frustrated over a contract dispute, deliberately deleted critical member data before quitting. The resulting business loss required over $50,000 in data reconstruction and temporary closures.
Total Claim Cost: $52,100 (data recovery, loss of income, attorney fees)
Sarah's Cost: $52,100.
The claim was denied due to the policy exclusion for intentional insider acts.
"I assumed cyber insurance covered any data loss. It was devastating to realize our biggest risk was from someone on the inside."
Undocumented Training Costs a Brewery – Pearl Street, Boulder
Background: Mike owns a craft brewery on Pearl Street with 22 staff and digital POS systems.
Coverage: $500,000 cyber policy, $3,000 deductible, $48/month ($576/year)
The Incident: A new employee clicked on a phishing email, exposing payroll data. Review revealed no documentation of recent staff cybersecurity training, as required by the insurer.
Total Claim Cost: $38,800 (fraud recovery, legal, new security software)
Mike's Cost: Full $38,800.
Because Mike couldn’t provide proof of mandatory cybersecurity training, the claim was excluded.
"Losing coverage over missing paperwork was a tough lesson. Now we document every training and keep a checklist for our insurance reviews."
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Believing All Cyber Risks Are Automatically Covered
What People Do: Purchase cyber liability insurance and assume it applies to any IT-related loss or data breach, regardless of circumstances.
Why It Seems Logical: The coverage name suggests broad protection, and policy exclusions are often buried in dense language.
The Real Cost: In Colorado and Utah, one uncovered incident can cost local businesses $50,000 to $200,000 out of pocket—well beyond what most could absorb.
Smart Alternative: Review your policy’s exclusions in plain language with a FoCoIns advisor. Clarify what’s covered and what’s not, and use this knowledge to create an effective risk management plan.
Mistake #2: Neglecting Cybersecurity Basics After Getting Coverage
What People Do: Stop focusing on updates, password controls, and staff training after purchasing a policy, assuming insurance is a backstop for any breach.
Why It Seems Logical: A sense of “set it and forget it” protection feels efficient—especially for busy business owners.
The Real Cost: Local insurers in CO and UT directly cite lack of basic IT maintenance as grounds for claims denial, leaving businesses to cover average losses of $187,000 themselves.
Smart Alternative: Make regular system updates and employee cyber training part of your business routine. Keep clear records for both to safeguard your coverage and demonstrate compliance if you file a claim.
Mistake #3: Failing to Document Training and Security Steps
What People Do: Rely on “verbal” processes rather than documented checklists or logs for staff cyber trainings and IT audits.
Why It Seems Logical: Small teams trust each other, and formal paperwork feels unnecessary or burdensome.
The Real Cost: In denied claims, insurers often ask for written proof of compliance. Businesses from Denver to Provo have lost six-figure claims because documentation was lacking, despite actually following best practices.
Smart Alternative: Institute a simple schedule and log for every cybersecurity update and all employee trainings. This protects your business and is a requirement for claim approval with many leading policies.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.