How often should I review my insurance policies with my broker?
You should review your commercial insurance policies at least once a year or after any major business change. Regular check-ins help ensure you're fully protected and compliant in Colorado and Utah.
Your trusted Colorado and Utah insurance advisor, providing customized guidance for local businesses.
Complete Guide to Reviewing Your Commercial Insurance Policies
Why This Question Matters for Colorado and Utah Residents
For business owners in Colorado and Utah, annual insurance reviews aren't just a formality—they're a critical safeguard against evolving risks and regulatory changes. Local hazards like hailstorms, wildfires, and rising litigation costs can dramatically shift your exposure profile year to year. Additionally, policy requirements and premium rates often change with state-specific laws and economic conditions.
- Rapid Business Changes: Opening a new location in Fort Collins or expanding operations in Salt Lake City means your old coverage may no longer fit. An annual review keeps your protection in sync with real growth.
- Regional Risk Factors: Colorado's Front Range businesses see some of the nation’s highest hail-related claims, with average property losses now exceeding $42,800 per event. Utah business owners must adapt to wildfire and seasonal water damage threats. Both states are experiencing a 15–40% annual increase in commercial premiums due to these regional patterns.
- Regulatory Compliance: Colorado and Utah routinely update commercial insurance requirements. Missing a mandated coverage update could lead to penalties—or uncovered claims should the worst happen.
What Most People Get Wrong
Many business owners believe that policies are “set it and forget it.” In reality, failing to update your insurance as your operations, assets, or local laws change puts you at risk for surprise claim denials or costly gaps.
Another misconception is reviewing only when premiums increase; in truth, both growth and downsizing can require fine-tuning your protection to avoid paying too much or leaving exposures uninsured.
The Complete Picture
A best-practice approach includes a full policy review with your broker at least annually—ideally during your renewal window or after significant changes:
- Adding or removing locations, vehicles, or equipment
- Hiring more employees (which impacts workers’ comp rates)
- Changing business operations, services, or products
- Major lease or contract updates
In Colorado, 78.4% of insurance market premiums are commercial lines, and 40% of businesses never reopen after a major uncovered loss—underscoring the value of catching new risks early. Structured broker reviews also identify premium-saving credits (like for hail-resistant roofing), and help ensure industry-specific compliance as regulations shift locally.
Making the Right Decision for Colorado and Utah Residents
Question 1: What business changes have occurred since your last review?
Take inventory of growth, downsizing, or operational shifts relevant to your coverage needs.
- New property or equipment?
- Added products or services?
- Staff changes impacting workers' comp?
Question 2: Are you meeting all Colorado/Utah legal requirements for your industry?
Both states regularly update coverage mandates and industry obligations. Local brokers are equipped to ensure you’re fully compliant—and avoid penalties.
Question 3: How could emerging regional risks threaten your operation?
Assess regional data: Are claims for hail, fire, or cyber threats rising in your area? Proactively adjust limits, deductibles, or add endorsements as needed to maintain resilience.
Trusted by Your Neighbors
Local knowledge, industry-leading protection
4.9/5 Stars
Google Reviews from real customers
97% Retention Rate
Fort Collins families and businesses protected
Independent
We work for you, not insurance companies
Local
Fort Collins owned & operated since 1992
Real World Examples
Harmony Road Retailer: Annual Review Saves the Day in Fort Collins, CO
Background: Emily owns a boutique retail store on Harmony Road in Fort Collins. Last year, she expanded to offer online sales and invested in $60,000 of new inventory.
Coverage: Commercial property and cyber liability package, $500,000 general liability, $100,000 business interruption.
Monthly Premium: $212/month ($2,544/year)
The Incident: Just before peak season, a hailstorm caused roof damage and inventory loss, while a cyber-attack coincided with repairs. Emily's regular annual review ensured both property and cyber coverage were up to date, covering both losses.
Total Claim Cost: $48,500 (property: $38,000, cyber: $10,500)
Emily's Cost: $2,500 deductible - Her annual review caught new online risks, allowing for a seamless, full recovery.
"I’m so grateful my broker understood local risks and made time for our yearly review. Without it, I might have lost the store!"
Salt Lake Manufacturer: New Machinery, New Coverage
Background: Carlos, owner of a light manufacturing business near I-15 in Salt Lake City, invested in $120,000 in new machinery and expanded his team over the year.
Coverage: Commercial property ($300,000 limit), equipment breakdown, workers’ compensation, $2M liability umbrella.
Monthly Premium: $410/month ($4,920/year)
The Incident: Two months after the annual review, a machine malfunction caused a fire and minor worker injury. The new equipment and staff were fully disclosed and covered thanks to the recent policy update.
Total Claim Cost: $65,000 (equipment/property: $55,000, medical: $10,000)
Carlos's Cost: $5,000 deductible + small copay—no major coverage gaps.
"My business would have faced huge losses if we hadn’t reviewed everything after expanding. The coverage my broker recommended made all the difference."
Boulder's Growing Nonprofit: Avoiding a Coverage Gap
Background: Sara directs a Boulder-based nonprofit that doubled its staff for a new program but forgot to update payroll estimates and liability limits that year.
Coverage: General liability ($1M), nonprofit directors & officers (D&O), workers’ comp, event coverage.
Monthly Premium: $365/month ($4,380/year)
The Incident: During an onsite event, a slip-and-fall resulted in a lawsuit. Because the broker had proactively scheduled an annual review, Sara’s updated policy reflected the higher employee count and exposure.
Total Claim Cost: $104,000 (medical/legal)
Sara's Cost: $0 (incident fully covered because all changes were reviewed in advance)
"Had we skipped our policy review, the suit might have bankrupted our project. Our broker’s insight saved us—literally."
Avoid These Common Mistakes
Mistake #1: Assuming 'No News' Means Adequate Coverage
What People Do: Business owners often believe that if they haven't had claims or premium hikes, there's no need for a review. They keep renewal on autopilot year after year.
Why It Seems Logical: If costs are steady and nothing dramatic has happened, it's easy to think coverage is just fine.
The Real Cost: In Colorado, hail claim frequency jumped 63% over five years, while new cyber threats have led to average losses of $187,000 per attack. Missed coverage updates could leave you responsible for six-figure losses—or denied claims.
Smart Alternative: Schedule a proactive annual review with your broker, even if nothing dramatic changed, to spot newly emerging risks and secure relevant premium credits.
Mistake #2: Skipping Reviews After Business Changes
What People Do: Businesses that add equipment, new staff, or locations but don’t notify their broker risk serious exposure changes going unnoticed.
Why It Seems Logical: When busy running operations, administrative updates can slip through the cracks.
The Real Cost: A business could pay $25,000–$65,000 out-of-pocket for a claim involving uninsured new property or an injury to an unreported staff member, especially in high-risk industries like construction or manufacturing.
Smart Alternative: Immediately notify your broker of any material changes throughout the year, and ensure these are reviewed at minimum during your annual check-in.
Mistake #3: Focusing Only on Price, Not Protection
What People Do: Some business owners request the lowest possible premium without reviewing what is being excluded or what limits are set.
Why It Seems Logical: With rising premiums (up to 40% YoY in CO/UT), it’s tempting to reduce costs by reducing coverage, especially in a tight economy.
The Real Cost: Dropping business interruption or umbrella coverage to save $40–$70/month can lead to uncovered losses—such as being unable to reopen after a disaster, with 40% of uncovered businesses closing permanently after a major event.
Smart Alternative: Work with a knowledgeable broker, like FoCoIns, to find balanced coverage that fits your budget and adequately addresses your exposures—leveraging credits and adjusting deductibles without sacrificing essential protection.
FAQs On The Same Topic
Find answers to your most pressing insurance questions right here.